Difference between revisions of "Nuclear power"

From Marspedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 5: Line 5:
  
 
==Usage On Mars==
 
==Usage On Mars==
The generation of electricity from nuclear fuel does not depend on [[environmental conditions|weather conditions]] so would be useful for maintaining a reliable source of power on Mars. Thorium is available on Mars in large deposits at Mid latitudes, this is the preferred fuel in Molten Salt Reactors particularly Liquid Fuel Thorium Reactors LFTRs.
+
The generation of electricity from nuclear fuel does not depend on [[environmental conditions|weather conditions]] so would be useful for maintaining a reliable source of power on Mars. Thorium is available on Mars in large low concentration deposits at Mid latitudes.  This is the preferred fuel in Molten Salt Reactors, particularly Liquid Fuel Thorium Reactors LFTRs.
 +
 
 +
Most nuclear reactors designs have a thermal efficiency of about 35%.  This means 35% of the heat from the core can be turned into electricity, the rest needs to be dissipated as low grade heat into the environment. This makes nuclear reactors useful for combined services, where electricity and heat can be used by a settlement.
 +
 
 +
Nuclear reactors might be required during long dust storms, when the power from solar arrays could dip low enough to endanger a solar powered colony.
  
 
===Molten Salt Energy Storage===
 
===Molten Salt Energy Storage===
Molten Salt Energy Storage <ref name=":1">Molten Salt Energy Storage, Solarreserve '' MOLTEN SALT ENERGY STORAGE '', https://www.solarreserve.com/en/technology/molten-salt-energy-storage</ref>  is a process used in Concentrated Solar Thermal <ref name=":2">Concentrated Solar Thermal, BY ROBERT DIETERICH '' Concentrated Solar Thermal '', https://apnews.com/Business%20Wire/832487eb77e04612af8bde5f7642f0f7</ref> that allows storing large amounts of heat energy in the form of high temperature molten salt.  This reserve can be tapped for direct use in colony heating, Evaporative water purification, and Rodriguez Wells<ref name=":3">Rodwell, Raul Rodriguez '' South Pole Station - Rodwells '', https://www.southpolestation.com/trivia/rodwell/rodwell.html</ref>.
+
Molten Salt Energy Storage <ref name=":1">Molten Salt Energy Storage, Solarreserve '' MOLTEN SALT ENERGY STORAGE '', https://www.solarreserve.com/en/technology/molten-salt-energy-storage</ref>  is a process used in Concentrated Solar Thermal <ref name=":2">Concentrated Solar Thermal, BY ROBERT DIETERICH '' Concentrated Solar Thermal '', https://apnews.com/Business%20Wire/832487eb77e04612af8bde5f7642f0f7</ref> that allows storing large amounts of heat energy in the form of high temperature molten salt.  This reserve can be tapped for direct use in colony heating, Evaporative water purification, and Rodriguez Wells<ref name=":3">Rodwell, Raul Rodriguez '' South Pole Station - Rodwells '', https://www.southpolestation.com/trivia/rodwell/rodwell.html</ref>.  However, the mass of the molten salts is high and the amount required might be prohibitive.  It may prove more economical to use the waste heat from an operating reactor directly, as nuclear reactors are the most efficient when they operate continuously.
  
===Rodriguez Well (RODWELL)===
+
===Rodriguez Well (RODWELL) for water production===
 
RODWELLS Are a form of well melted into Antarctic Ice to provide a constant source of water for use on a base, this lowers a heat source deep into the ice melting an area of ice that is partially pumped out as the ice cave grows <ref name=":3">Rodwell, Raul Rodriguez '' South Pole Station - Rodwells '', https://www.southpolestation.com/trivia/rodwell/rodwell.html</ref> Dr Chris Zacny has a brief on drilling RODWELLS for the Mars Society from the 21st annual Mars Society Convention https://youtu.be/NFDOrpljNAY
 
RODWELLS Are a form of well melted into Antarctic Ice to provide a constant source of water for use on a base, this lowers a heat source deep into the ice melting an area of ice that is partially pumped out as the ice cave grows <ref name=":3">Rodwell, Raul Rodriguez '' South Pole Station - Rodwells '', https://www.southpolestation.com/trivia/rodwell/rodwell.html</ref> Dr Chris Zacny has a brief on drilling RODWELLS for the Mars Society from the 21st annual Mars Society Convention https://youtu.be/NFDOrpljNAY
  
===Supercritical CO2 Turbines===
+
Waste heat from nuclear reactor cooling could be used to melt ice in this type of wells.
Supercritical CO2 Turbines, use high pressure CO2 to drive a turbine engine at high efficency to generate power, combined with a Liquid Fuel Thorium Reactor a unit the size of a desk can generate 10mw of energy. <ref name=":4">Supercritical CO2: The Path to Less-Expensive, “Greener” Energy, Machine Design '' Supercritical CO2: The Path to Less-Expensive, “Greener” Energy '', https://www.machinedesign.com/mechanical/supercritical-co2-path-less-expensive-greener-energy</ref>
+
 
 +
===Supercritical CO2 Turbines for electrical production===
 +
Supercritical CO2 Turbines use high pressure CO2 to drive a small turbine and compressor system at high efficency to generate power.  Combined with a Liquid Fuel Thorium Reactor, a unit the size of a desk might generate 10 MW of power. <ref name=":4">Supercritical CO2: The Path to Less-Expensive, “Greener” Energy, Machine Design '' Supercritical CO2: The Path to Less-Expensive, “Greener” Energy '', https://www.machinedesign.com/mechanical/supercritical-co2-path-less-expensive-greener-energy</ref>
  
 
==Nuclear reactor==
 
==Nuclear reactor==
In a Light Water Reactor, heat caused by the radioactivity boils [[water]] to steam. [[turbine|Turbines]] are driven by the steam's pressure, spinning a dynamo to generate electric energy.  In a Molten Salt Reactor the heat generated from the core is redirected for use in Molten Salt Thermal Storage, structural heating, Stirling Generators to provide electricity, Evaporative Water Purification, and to melt water in RODWELLS.  In a Heatpipe reactor a solid core generates heat that is transferred via "Heatpipe"<ref name=":5">Inspired Heat-Pipe Technology,  Los Alamos '' Inspired Heat-Pipe Technology '', https://www.lanl.gov/science/NSS/issue1_2011/story6full.shtml</ref> technology to Stirling Generators with the option to transfer the heat tp Molten Salt Storage for further direct heat energy use or Stirling Generators or Supercritical CO2 Turbines at separate locations in the colony.
+
In a Light Water Reactor, heat caused by the radioactivity boils [[water]] to steam. [[turbine|Turbines]] are driven by the steam's pressure, spinning a generator to generate electric energy.  In a Molten Salt Reactor the heat generated from the core is redirected for use in Molten Salt Thermal Storage, structural heating, Stirling Generators to provide electricity, Evaporative Water Purification, and to melt water in RODWELLS.  In a Heatpipe reactor a solid core generates heat that is transferred via "Heatpipe"<ref name=":5">Inspired Heat-Pipe Technology,  Los Alamos '' Inspired Heat-Pipe Technology '', https://www.lanl.gov/science/NSS/issue1_2011/story6full.shtml</ref> technology to Stirling Generators with the option to transfer the heat to Molten Salt Storage for further direct heat energy use or Stirling Generators or Supercritical CO2 Turbines at separate locations in the colony.
  
 
==Nuclear heating==
 
==Nuclear heating==
Heating [[greenhouse]]s and other [[building]]s may be done indirectly by the heat of the nuclear fission. The heat can be transported in pipes from the reactor to the buildings. Heat exchangers avoid nuclear pollution of the buildings.
+
Heating [[greenhouse]]s and other [[building]]s may be done indirectly by the waste heat of the nuclear fission. The heat can be transported in pipes from the reactor to the buildings. Heat exchangers avoid radiation pollution of the buildings.
  
==Types of Nuclear Generation==
+
==Types of Nuclear Generation designs==
  
 
===RTG===
 
===RTG===
Line 29: Line 35:
  
 
===Nuclear Heatpipe Reactor===
 
===Nuclear Heatpipe Reactor===
The Kilopower project designs are Heat-Pipe Reactors <ref name=":6">Megawatt Level Heat-Pipe Reactors, Mcclure, Patrick Ray Poston, David Irvin Dasari, Venkateswara Rao Reid, Robert Stowers '' DESIGN OF MEGAWATT POWER LEVEL HEAT PIPE REACTORS  '', https://permalink.lanl.gov/object/tr?what=info:lanl-repo/lareport/LA-UR-15-28840, Nov 2015.</ref>  that offer stable, safe power that requires no outside support system or personnel and is immune to meltdown. They can be scaled from .5 kW to 50 MW for remote bases, small cities, and mining sites on Earth.  On Mars and in space, these reactors could power a Colony or a Spaceship for between 5 and 40 years with no maintenance except replacement of the sterling engines and with no in-situ resources needed. Heatpipe Reactors are inherently safe.  If no energy is removed, the system stabilizes to a constant temperature. Heat-Pipe Reactors are inherently "Walk-Away Safe" meaning if an emergency happens and the reactor is left alone it will not melt down or change state.<ref name=":7">Solid-Core Heat-Pipe Nuclear Battery Type Reactor, Ehud Greenspan'' Solid-Core Heat-Pipe Nuclear Battery Type Reactor '', https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/940911</ref> <ref name=":8">Idaho National Labs, Dr. K.P Annath, Dr. Michael Kellar, Mr. James Werner, Dr James Sterbentz '' Portable Special Purpose Nuclear Reactor (2 MW) for Remote Operating Bases and Microgrids '', https://ndiastorage.blob.core.usgovcloudapi.net/ndia/2017/power/Ananth19349.pdf, May 2017.</ref> <ref name=":9">NASA Kilopower Project, Dr. David Poston '' Small Nuclear Reactors for Mars - 21st Annual Mars Society Convention '', https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NLE5YFuCmhw, Sep 2018.</ref>
+
The Kilopower project designs are Heat-Pipe Reactors <ref name=":6">Megawatt Level Heat-Pipe Reactors, Mcclure, Patrick Ray Poston, David Irvin Dasari, Venkateswara Rao Reid, Robert Stowers '' DESIGN OF MEGAWATT POWER LEVEL HEAT PIPE REACTORS  '', https://permalink.lanl.gov/object/tr?what=info:lanl-repo/lareport/LA-UR-15-28840, Nov 2015.</ref>  that offer stable, safe power that requires no outside support system or personnel and is immune to meltdown. Their operating efficiency as electrical generators is about 23%.  They can be scaled from .5 kW to 50 MW for remote bases, small cities, and mining sites on Earth.  On Mars and in space, these reactors could power a Settlement or a Spaceship for between 5 to 40 years with no maintenance except replacement of the sterling engines and with no in-situ resources needed. Heatpipe Reactors are inherently safe.  If no energy is removed, the system stabilizes to a constant temperature that is bellow the melting temperature of the components. Heat-Pipe Reactors are inherently "Walk-Away Safe" meaning if an emergency happens and the reactor is left alone it will not melt down or change state.<ref name=":7">Solid-Core Heat-Pipe Nuclear Battery Type Reactor, Ehud Greenspan'' Solid-Core Heat-Pipe Nuclear Battery Type Reactor '', https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/940911</ref> <ref name=":8">Idaho National Labs, Dr. K.P Annath, Dr. Michael Kellar, Mr. James Werner, Dr James Sterbentz '' Portable Special Purpose Nuclear Reactor (2 MW) for Remote Operating Bases and Microgrids '', https://ndiastorage.blob.core.usgovcloudapi.net/ndia/2017/power/Ananth19349.pdf, May 2017.</ref> <ref name=":9">NASA Kilopower Project, Dr. David Poston '' Small Nuclear Reactors for Mars - 21st Annual Mars Society Convention '', https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NLE5YFuCmhw, Sep 2018.</ref>
  
However, these reactors do have secondary systems, such as sterling engines connected to generators to produce electric power, and radiators to dissipate excess heat.
+
However, these reactors do have secondary systems, such as sterling engines connected to generators to produce electric power, and radiators to dissipate excess heat.  These add to the mass of the reactor, making the system somewhat less advantageous.
  
 
===Molten Salt Reactor===
 
===Molten Salt Reactor===
Molten Salt Reactors use a liquid salt fuel that suspends a nuclear fuel in the salt at atmospheric pressure as opposed to a solid fuel reactor that uses high pressure water as a cooling agent that can turn into a steam explosion.  If the salt temperature rises it will separate the suspended nuclear fuel and slow the reaction, as a safety feature at the lowest point in the core a pipe is cooled forcing the salt in that section of pipe to freeze and create a plug of salt, if that external cooling is lost the plug melts and the liquid salt contents of the core dump into a storage tank, when the salt is separated from the graphite moderator the salt becomes sub-critical and cools down. In the unlikely event of a leak of the Salt solidifies quickly allowing for far easier cleanup vs liquid water seeping into the environment.  Since no pressurized steam is involved there is no need for a large domed pressure building around the core.  For a more detailed explanation from Dr. Kirk Sorensen please see https://youtu.be/D3rL08J7fDA <ref name=":10">Safety assessment of molten salt reactors in comparison with light water reactors, Badawy M.Elsheikh '' Safety assessment of molten salt reactors in comparison with light water reactors '', https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1687850713000101, Oct, 2013.</ref> <ref name=":11">How Molten Salt Reactors Might Spell a Nuclear Energy Revolution,  Stephen Williams '' How Molten Salt Reactors Might Spell a Nuclear Energy Revolution '', https://www.zmescience.com/ecology/what-is-molten-salt-reactor-424343/, Feb 2019.</ref>
+
Molten Salt Reactors use a liquid salt fuel that suspends a nuclear fuel in the salt at atmospheric pressure as opposed to a solid fuel reactor that uses high pressure water as a cooling agent that can turn into a steam explosion.  If the salt temperature rises it will separate the suspended nuclear fuel and slow the reaction.  As a safety feature, at the lowest point in the core a pipe is cooled forcing the salt in that section of pipe to freeze and create a plug of salt, if that external cooling is lost the plug melts and the liquid salt contents of the core dump into a storage tank, when the salt is separated from the graphite moderator.  The salt becomes sub-critical and cools down. In the event of a leak, the Salt solidifies quickly allowing for far easier cleanup vs liquid water seeping into the environment.  Since no pressurized steam is involved there is no need for a large domed pressure building around the core.  For a more detailed explanation from Dr. Kirk Sorensen please see https://youtu.be/D3rL08J7fDA <ref name=":10">Safety assessment of molten salt reactors in comparison with light water reactors, Badawy M.Elsheikh '' Safety assessment of molten salt reactors in comparison with light water reactors '', https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1687850713000101, Oct, 2013.</ref> <ref name=":11">How Molten Salt Reactors Might Spell a Nuclear Energy Revolution,  Stephen Williams '' How Molten Salt Reactors Might Spell a Nuclear Energy Revolution '', https://www.zmescience.com/ecology/what-is-molten-salt-reactor-424343/, Feb 2019.</ref>
  
 
==Nuclear Fuel Sources on Mars==
 
==Nuclear Fuel Sources on Mars==

Revision as of 10:42, 25 April 2019

Nuclear Danger Icon

Nuclear Power is a method of energy generation. It uses nuclear fuel to produce heat, which is usually transformed into electricity. Nuclear power is considered the preferred energy source for most plans for medium- to long-term human expeditions to Mars.


Usage On Mars

The generation of electricity from nuclear fuel does not depend on weather conditions so would be useful for maintaining a reliable source of power on Mars. Thorium is available on Mars in large low concentration deposits at Mid latitudes. This is the preferred fuel in Molten Salt Reactors, particularly Liquid Fuel Thorium Reactors LFTRs.

Most nuclear reactors designs have a thermal efficiency of about 35%. This means 35% of the heat from the core can be turned into electricity, the rest needs to be dissipated as low grade heat into the environment. This makes nuclear reactors useful for combined services, where electricity and heat can be used by a settlement.

Nuclear reactors might be required during long dust storms, when the power from solar arrays could dip low enough to endanger a solar powered colony.

Molten Salt Energy Storage

Molten Salt Energy Storage [1] is a process used in Concentrated Solar Thermal [2] that allows storing large amounts of heat energy in the form of high temperature molten salt. This reserve can be tapped for direct use in colony heating, Evaporative water purification, and Rodriguez Wells[3]. However, the mass of the molten salts is high and the amount required might be prohibitive. It may prove more economical to use the waste heat from an operating reactor directly, as nuclear reactors are the most efficient when they operate continuously.

Rodriguez Well (RODWELL) for water production

RODWELLS Are a form of well melted into Antarctic Ice to provide a constant source of water for use on a base, this lowers a heat source deep into the ice melting an area of ice that is partially pumped out as the ice cave grows [3] Dr Chris Zacny has a brief on drilling RODWELLS for the Mars Society from the 21st annual Mars Society Convention https://youtu.be/NFDOrpljNAY

Waste heat from nuclear reactor cooling could be used to melt ice in this type of wells.

Supercritical CO2 Turbines for electrical production

Supercritical CO2 Turbines use high pressure CO2 to drive a small turbine and compressor system at high efficency to generate power. Combined with a Liquid Fuel Thorium Reactor, a unit the size of a desk might generate 10 MW of power. [4]

Nuclear reactor

In a Light Water Reactor, heat caused by the radioactivity boils water to steam. Turbines are driven by the steam's pressure, spinning a generator to generate electric energy. In a Molten Salt Reactor the heat generated from the core is redirected for use in Molten Salt Thermal Storage, structural heating, Stirling Generators to provide electricity, Evaporative Water Purification, and to melt water in RODWELLS. In a Heatpipe reactor a solid core generates heat that is transferred via "Heatpipe"[5] technology to Stirling Generators with the option to transfer the heat to Molten Salt Storage for further direct heat energy use or Stirling Generators or Supercritical CO2 Turbines at separate locations in the colony.

Nuclear heating

Heating greenhouses and other buildings may be done indirectly by the waste heat of the nuclear fission. The heat can be transported in pipes from the reactor to the buildings. Heat exchangers avoid radiation pollution of the buildings.

Types of Nuclear Generation designs

RTG

Radioisotope thermoelectric generators (abbr.: RTG) are simple devices. They produce a heat difference, transformed by a thermocouple to electrical energy. The maintenance effort is low. However, RTGs do not provide enough power for a base. Furthermore RTG depend on plutonium as a power source, and the supply is extremely low[6], in the order of a few kg.

Nuclear Heatpipe Reactor

The Kilopower project designs are Heat-Pipe Reactors [7] that offer stable, safe power that requires no outside support system or personnel and is immune to meltdown. Their operating efficiency as electrical generators is about 23%. They can be scaled from .5 kW to 50 MW for remote bases, small cities, and mining sites on Earth. On Mars and in space, these reactors could power a Settlement or a Spaceship for between 5 to 40 years with no maintenance except replacement of the sterling engines and with no in-situ resources needed. Heatpipe Reactors are inherently safe. If no energy is removed, the system stabilizes to a constant temperature that is bellow the melting temperature of the components. Heat-Pipe Reactors are inherently "Walk-Away Safe" meaning if an emergency happens and the reactor is left alone it will not melt down or change state.[8] [9] [10]

However, these reactors do have secondary systems, such as sterling engines connected to generators to produce electric power, and radiators to dissipate excess heat. These add to the mass of the reactor, making the system somewhat less advantageous.

Molten Salt Reactor

Molten Salt Reactors use a liquid salt fuel that suspends a nuclear fuel in the salt at atmospheric pressure as opposed to a solid fuel reactor that uses high pressure water as a cooling agent that can turn into a steam explosion. If the salt temperature rises it will separate the suspended nuclear fuel and slow the reaction. As a safety feature, at the lowest point in the core a pipe is cooled forcing the salt in that section of pipe to freeze and create a plug of salt, if that external cooling is lost the plug melts and the liquid salt contents of the core dump into a storage tank, when the salt is separated from the graphite moderator. The salt becomes sub-critical and cools down. In the event of a leak, the Salt solidifies quickly allowing for far easier cleanup vs liquid water seeping into the environment. Since no pressurized steam is involved there is no need for a large domed pressure building around the core. For a more detailed explanation from Dr. Kirk Sorensen please see https://youtu.be/D3rL08J7fDA [11] [12]

Nuclear Fuel Sources on Mars

Thorium Deposits on Mars

JPL has identified Thorium deposits on Mars, this is the preferred fuel in a number of Molten Salt Reactor designs. [13]

However, it is important to note that high concentration in this case means 1ppm, and that common soil on Earth has a concentration of 6ppm. There are granitic deposits on Earth with Thorium concentrations of 56ppm, that are considered very low grade resources. There is no evidence yet of thorium ores that might be mined in an economical way.

In general, Thorium maps made from Mars Odyssey data suggest that the martian crust is poor in Thorium or uranium. It is possible that this reflects a formation model for Mars that would be much poorer in heavy metals than for Earth, and that Mars might have formed with more volatiles. This might be an explanation for Mars' lower density compared to Earth, 3.95 tonnes per m3 (g/cm3) vs 5,51 tonnes per m3 (g/cm3) for Earth.

Open issues

  • What sort of nuclear fuel is needed?
  • How long can the described nuclear power stations work without replenishment of nuclear fuel?
  • What is known about nuclear resources on Mars?

References

  1. Molten Salt Energy Storage, Solarreserve MOLTEN SALT ENERGY STORAGE , https://www.solarreserve.com/en/technology/molten-salt-energy-storage
  2. Concentrated Solar Thermal, BY ROBERT DIETERICH Concentrated Solar Thermal , https://apnews.com/Business%20Wire/832487eb77e04612af8bde5f7642f0f7
  3. 3.0 3.1 Rodwell, Raul Rodriguez South Pole Station - Rodwells , https://www.southpolestation.com/trivia/rodwell/rodwell.html
  4. Supercritical CO2: The Path to Less-Expensive, “Greener” Energy, Machine Design Supercritical CO2: The Path to Less-Expensive, “Greener” Energy , https://www.machinedesign.com/mechanical/supercritical-co2-path-less-expensive-greener-energy
  5. Inspired Heat-Pipe Technology, Los Alamos Inspired Heat-Pipe Technology , https://www.lanl.gov/science/NSS/issue1_2011/story6full.shtml
  6. https://spacenews.com/plutonium-supply-for-nasa-missions-faces-long-term-challenges/
  7. Megawatt Level Heat-Pipe Reactors, Mcclure, Patrick Ray Poston, David Irvin Dasari, Venkateswara Rao Reid, Robert Stowers DESIGN OF MEGAWATT POWER LEVEL HEAT PIPE REACTORS , https://permalink.lanl.gov/object/tr?what=info:lanl-repo/lareport/LA-UR-15-28840, Nov 2015.
  8. Solid-Core Heat-Pipe Nuclear Battery Type Reactor, Ehud Greenspan Solid-Core Heat-Pipe Nuclear Battery Type Reactor , https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/940911
  9. Idaho National Labs, Dr. K.P Annath, Dr. Michael Kellar, Mr. James Werner, Dr James Sterbentz Portable Special Purpose Nuclear Reactor (2 MW) for Remote Operating Bases and Microgrids , https://ndiastorage.blob.core.usgovcloudapi.net/ndia/2017/power/Ananth19349.pdf, May 2017.
  10. NASA Kilopower Project, Dr. David Poston Small Nuclear Reactors for Mars - 21st Annual Mars Society Convention , https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NLE5YFuCmhw, Sep 2018.
  11. Safety assessment of molten salt reactors in comparison with light water reactors, Badawy M.Elsheikh Safety assessment of molten salt reactors in comparison with light water reactors , https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1687850713000101, Oct, 2013.
  12. How Molten Salt Reactors Might Spell a Nuclear Energy Revolution, Stephen Williams How Molten Salt Reactors Might Spell a Nuclear Energy Revolution , https://www.zmescience.com/ecology/what-is-molten-salt-reactor-424343/, Feb 2019.
  13. Map of Martian Thorium at Mid-Latitudes, JPL Map of Martian Thorium at Mid-Latitudes , https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/spaceimages/details.php?id=PIA04257, March 2003.

External links

  • None