Difference between revisions of "Embodied energy"
m (→Discussion) |
|||
| (17 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
==In common materials (from Wikipedia, partially adapted to Mars)== | ==In common materials (from Wikipedia, partially adapted to Mars)== | ||
| − | Selected data from the Inventory of Carbon and Energy ('ICE') prepared by the University of Bath (UK) | + | *Selected data from the Inventory of Carbon and Energy ('ICE') prepared by the University of Bath (UK) |
| + | *Note that for all wood, paper, fiber and other biologically produced products, as well as for many plastics, the energy cost of biomass should be added to the embodied energy. | ||
{| class="wikitable sortable" | {| class="wikitable sortable" | ||
!'''Material''' | !'''Material''' | ||
| Line 46: | Line 47: | ||
|ML | |ML | ||
|- | |- | ||
| − | |'''Food''' | + | |'''Food and biomass''' |
| − | | | + | |1300 |
|900-1000 | |900-1000 | ||
| − | |This | + | |Based on 250 W/m2 lighting and 60 mT/ha/y food production. This energy produces an equivalent yield of biomass. Food provides, on average, 3.87 MJ of energy per kg. |
|ML | |ML | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Line 317: | Line 318: | ||
| | | | ||
|} | |} | ||
| − | Plastics, for example, have a high value of embodied energy and therefore are not the best choices for construction materials, of other choices are available. '''Note, energy in plastic feedstock is included, although these are for feedstocks on Earth. The feedstock energy on Mars is probably higher as it is all | + | Plastics, for example, have a high value of embodied energy and therefore are not the best choices for construction materials, of other choices are available. '''Note, energy in plastic feedstock is included, although these are for feedstocks on Earth. The feedstock energy on Mars is probably higher as it is all sourced from methane.''' |
Aluminium requires much more energy than Steel or iron and therefore is less likely to be used for construction on Mars. However, both steel and aluminium production on Earth uses coke, that embodies significant energy that is not counted in the evaluation made for Earth but would need to be added for Mars . ''TBC.'' | Aluminium requires much more energy than Steel or iron and therefore is less likely to be used for construction on Mars. However, both steel and aluminium production on Earth uses coke, that embodies significant energy that is not counted in the evaluation made for Earth but would need to be added for Mars . ''TBC.'' | ||
| Line 325: | Line 326: | ||
With embodied solar energy: | With embodied solar energy: | ||
| − | Food: At an average yield of | + | Food: At an average yield of 60 tonnes per hectare, or 6 kg/m2, embodied energy is: 250 W/m2 x 24 x 365 x 3600 / 6kg/m2 = 1300 MJ/kg. '''Needs to be checked in detail. Embodied energy tables for food on Earth do not include solar power but only include energy used for fertilizer production, food production and transformation. This may add about 10-20 MJ/kg to food.''' |
Wood: At 4 tonnes per hectare for bamboo, embodied energy is about 1200 MJ/kg. Work to transform it into a usable product should be added from table above. | Wood: At 4 tonnes per hectare for bamboo, embodied energy is about 1200 MJ/kg. Work to transform it into a usable product should be added from table above. | ||
==Embodied energy in solar cells== | ==Embodied energy in solar cells== | ||
| − | Including cell manufacture, supports and structure. PV cells require very high amounts of energy to manufacture and are likely to be more economical to transport from Earth in the earlier stages of a colony. However, in the long term they produce far more energy than they embody, so solar can be envisioned as a sustainable energy production method for Mars. On | + | Including cell manufacture, supports and structure. PV cells require very high amounts of energy to manufacture and are likely to be more economical to transport from Earth in the earlier stages of a colony. However, in the long term they produce far more energy than they embody, so solar can be envisioned as a sustainable energy production method for Mars. On Earth solar cells produce their embodied energy in about one year or less. Mars should require 2+ years due to the lower solar constant. <ref name=":0" /> |
{| class="wikitable" | {| class="wikitable" | ||
|'''Photovoltaic (PV) Cells Type''' | |'''Photovoltaic (PV) Cells Type''' | ||
| Line 388: | Line 389: | ||
|100,000 | |100,000 | ||
|} | |} | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==Discussion== | ||
| + | Since biomass is produced at the same time as food in roughly equivalent quantities, it might be better to divide the energy of food into two, and ascribe half the energy to biomass. The biomass energy can then be added to products derived from biomass. | ||
==References== | ==References== | ||
<references /> | <references /> | ||
Latest revision as of 09:01, 24 September 2024
Embodied energy[1] on Mars is the measure of all the energy required for the preparation of products or services. It allows for a useful comparison of various materials that can be produced in-situ for the construction of martian settlements. The following table is cradle to gate: From mining to production to a finished product at the gate of the plant. A martian settlement will also use operational energy, for moving, heating and cooling the products. Most food product information does not include the solar energy required for growth but only the energy required for food production, fertilisation and transformation. Recycling and energy recovery can reduce embodied energy significantly.
Contents
In common materials (from Wikipedia, partially adapted to Mars)
- Selected data from the Inventory of Carbon and Energy ('ICE') prepared by the University of Bath (UK)
- Note that for all wood, paper, fiber and other biologically produced products, as well as for many plastics, the energy cost of biomass should be added to the embodied energy.
| Material | Energy MJ/kg | Density kg /m3 | Mars notes | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Water | 0,5 | 1000 | Melting or condensing from atmosphere | ML |
| Hydrogen | 180 | Electrolysis of water, 80% efficiency, this also produces large amounts of Oxygen | ML | |
| CO2 | 4 | 1 | Work of compression and liquefaction | ML |
| Nitrogen | 1 | 1 | Absorption using fibes and pressure differentials[2] | ML |
| Ammonia NH3 | 55 | 0,73 | 16% of the mass of protein is nitrogen. Hydrogen need to be produced by electrolysis, then combined with compressed atmospheric nitrogen and turned into ammonia via the Haber-Bosch. | |
| Propellant (CH4) | 127 | This includes the energy to produce the corresponding Oxygen, atmospheric compression and hydrogen electrolysis. The residual energy density of methane is 53,6 MJ/kg. | ML | |
| Food and biomass | 1300 | 900-1000 | Based on 250 W/m2 lighting and 60 mT/ha/y food production. This energy produces an equivalent yield of biomass. Food provides, on average, 3.87 MJ of energy per kg. | ML |
| Aggregate | 0.083 | 2240 | This is the energy required to crush and sort the aggregate that is used for concrete production or road building | |
| Compressed Regolith Blocks (CRB) | 0,5 | 2000 | 5% cement | ML |
| Concrete (1:1.5:3) | 1.11-2 | 2400 | This is for M20 concrete, slightly better than average concrete | |
| Bricks (common) | 3 | 1700 | ||
| Concrete block (Medium density) | 0.67 | 1450 | ||
| Aerated block | 3.5 | 750 | ||
| Limestone block | 0.85 | 2180 | ||
| Cement mortar (1:3) | 1.33 | Cement with sand mixed in | ||
| Glass | 15 | 2500 | Primary glass production. Toughened glass reaches 23 MJ/kg | |
| Steel (general, av. recycled content) | 35 new
20 recycled |
7800 | From Iron, mining and foundry included, as a finished product. Recycled value is about 60% recycled. | |
| Stainless steel | 56.7 | 7850 | From Iron, Meteoritic iron might require much less energy. Type 304. | |
| Aluminium (general & incl 33% recycled) | 155-220 | 2700 | Alumina is common, but perhaps not in concentrated ores | |
| Copper (average incl. 37% recycled) | 42-140 | 8600 | ||
| Lead (incl 61% recycled) | 25.21 | 11340 | ||
| Nickel | 165 | 8908 | ||
| Gold | 310000 | 19300 | ||
| Platinum | 190000 | 21447 | ||
| Timber (general, excludes sequestration) | 8.5 | 480–720 | Unlikely, at first. Bamboo glued structural elements might provide similar services | |
| Glue laminated timber | 12 | |||
| Cellulose insulation (loose fill) | 0.94–3.3+300 | 43 | ||
| Glass fibre insulation (glass wool) | 28 | 12 | ||
| Rockwool (slab) | 16.8 | 24 | ||
| Expanded Polystyrene insulation | 88.6 | 15–30 | ||
| Polyurethane insulation (rigid foam) | 101.5 | 30 | ||
| Straw bale | 0.91 | 100–110 | Probably much more expensive on Mars, depends on the value of biomass | |
| Mineral fibre roofing tile | 37 | 1850 | ||
| Clay tile | 6.5 | 1900 | Clay deposits are available | |
| Medium-density fibreboard | 11 | 680–760 | ||
| Plywood | 15 | 540–700 | ||
| Plasterboard | 6.75 | 800 | ||
| Gypsum plaster | 1.8 | 1120 | ||
| PVC (general) | 77.2 | 1380 | ||
| Vinyl flooring | 65.64 | 1200 | ||
| Terrazzo tiles | 1.4 | 1750 | ||
| Ceramic tiles | 10-12 | 2000 | ||
| Wood | 1200-1500 | 600-800 | Similar to food | ML |
| Wool carpet | 106 | Sheep on Mars? | ||
| Wallpaper | 36.4 | |||
| Vitrified clay pipe (DN 500) | 7.9 | Might be interesting for many uses | ||
| Ceramic sanitary ware | 29 | |||
| Paint - Water-borne | 59 | |||
| Paint - Solvent-borne | 97 | |||
| Carbon fiber composite[3] | 800 | 1800-2000 | ||
| Solar cells[4] | 2088 | Silicon cells, not installed. |
Plastics, for example, have a high value of embodied energy and therefore are not the best choices for construction materials, of other choices are available. Note, energy in plastic feedstock is included, although these are for feedstocks on Earth. The feedstock energy on Mars is probably higher as it is all sourced from methane.
Aluminium requires much more energy than Steel or iron and therefore is less likely to be used for construction on Mars. However, both steel and aluminium production on Earth uses coke, that embodies significant energy that is not counted in the evaluation made for Earth but would need to be added for Mars . TBC.
The values for wood products and other biological products in the above table do not include embodied solar energy.
With embodied solar energy:
Food: At an average yield of 60 tonnes per hectare, or 6 kg/m2, embodied energy is: 250 W/m2 x 24 x 365 x 3600 / 6kg/m2 = 1300 MJ/kg. Needs to be checked in detail. Embodied energy tables for food on Earth do not include solar power but only include energy used for fertilizer production, food production and transformation. This may add about 10-20 MJ/kg to food.
Wood: At 4 tonnes per hectare for bamboo, embodied energy is about 1200 MJ/kg. Work to transform it into a usable product should be added from table above.
Embodied energy in solar cells
Including cell manufacture, supports and structure. PV cells require very high amounts of energy to manufacture and are likely to be more economical to transport from Earth in the earlier stages of a colony. However, in the long term they produce far more energy than they embody, so solar can be envisioned as a sustainable energy production method for Mars. On Earth solar cells produce their embodied energy in about one year or less. Mars should require 2+ years due to the lower solar constant. [4]
| Photovoltaic (PV) Cells Type | Energy MJ per m2 | Carbon kg CO
2 per m2 |
| Monocrystalline (average) | 4750 | 242 |
| Polycrystalline (average) | 4070 | 208 |
| Thin film (average) | 1305 | 67 |
Embodied energy in consumer goods
From the University of Calgary Energy education website. For the table below the values are an aggregate of all of the energy within the objects, so there is no mass unit included, rather it is the amount of energy in the entire object.
| Embodied energy (MJ/functional unit)[5][6] | |
|---|---|
| Hair dryer | 79 |
| Coffee maker | 184 |
| LCD monitor | 963 |
| Smartphone | 1,000 |
| PC tower | 2,085 |
| Washing machine | 3,900 |
| Laptop | 4,500 |
| Refrigerator | 5,900 |
| Digital copier | 7,924 |
| Cell tower | 100,000 |
Discussion
Since biomass is produced at the same time as food in roughly equivalent quantities, it might be better to divide the energy of food into two, and ascribe half the energy to biomass. The biomass energy can then be added to products derived from biomass.
References
- ↑ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embodied_energy
- ↑ "A Sustainable Approach to the Supply of Nitrogen". Parker Hannifin, Filtration and Separation Division. Retrieved 5 March 2015
- ↑ Sunter, D.A., Morrow III, W.R., Cresko, J.W. and Liddell, H.P., 2015, July. The manufacturing energy intensity of carbon fiber reinforced polymer composites and its effect on life cycle energy use for vehicle door lightweighting. In Proceedings of the 20th International Conference on Composite Materials (ICCM), Copenhagen, Denmark.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 https://greenchemuoft.wordpress.com/2017/12/12/embodied-energy-and-solar-cells/
- ↑ N. Duque Ciceri, T.G. Gutowski, and M. Garetti. (Accessed September 13, 2015). A Tool to Estimate Materials and Manufacturing Energy for a Product [Online], Available: http://web.mit.edu/ebm/www/Publications/9_Paper.pdf
- ↑ B. Raghavan and J. Ma at UC Berkeley. (Accessed September 13, 2015). The Energy and Emergy of the Internet [Online], Available: http://conferences.sigcomm.org/hotnets/2011/papers/hotnetsX-final56.pdf
