Difference between revisions of "Insulation"

From Marspedia
Jump to: navigation, search
m (→‎Insulation table: Added link.)
 
(28 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
[[Image:foamed_polystyrene.jpg|right|frame|Sheets of foamed polystyrene for insulation of houses.]]
 
[[Image:foamed_polystyrene.jpg|right|frame|Sheets of foamed polystyrene for insulation of houses.]]
  
−
'''Insulation''' is needed to keep a [[colony]] warm and reduces the consumption of [[energy]] for heating. [[Aerogel]] or plastic [[foam]] may be utilized for insulation. [[Regolith]] may be heaped over buildings to keep in heat. [[Mineral wool|Mineral wools]], spun from local resources, may provide a lower tech alternative insulation. [[Fiberglass]], a type of mineral wool, is commonly used as insulation on Earth. [[Arsenic]] is a mineral that can be used as a heat tolerant insulation, but is toxic to life.
+
'''Thermal Insulation''' is needed to keep a [[colony]] warm and reduces the consumption of [[energy]] for heating. [[Aerogel]] or plastic [[foam]] may be utilized for insulation. [[Regolith]] may be heaped over buildings to keep in heat. [[Mineral wool|Mineral wools]] such as  [[Fiberglass]], spun from local resources, may provide alternative insulation.
  
 
[[Image:vacuum_flask.jpg|frame|The glass body of a vacuum flask.|alt=]]
 
[[Image:vacuum_flask.jpg|frame|The glass body of a vacuum flask.|alt=]]
  
 
==Insulation on Mars==
 
==Insulation on Mars==
−
The thin Martian [[atmosphere]] has a reduced capability for a convective flow of heat. More important is the heat radiation, which can be effectively reduced by choosing the material of the building's surface. A smooth bright metallic surface emits much less heat radiation than a rough black one. A simple [[aluminium]] coated foil wrapped around the settlement modules provides excellent insulation.  [[w:Multi-layer_insulation|Multi-layer insulation]] (MLI) of the same type of foil can reduce heat loss to very low numbers and is commonly used for satellites.  However, convection is still significant in insulation systems on Mars and this reduces the effectiveness of MLI<ref name=":0" />.
+
The thin Martian [[atmosphere]] has a reduced capability for a convective flow of heat. More important is the heat radiation, which can be effectively reduced by choosing the material of the building's surface. A smooth bright metallic surface emits much less heat radiation than a rough black one. A simple [[aluminium]] coated foil wrapped around the settlement modules provides excellent insulation.  [[w:Multi-layer_insulation|Multi-layer insulation]] (MLI) of the same type of foil can reduce heat loss to very low numbers and is commonly used for satellites.  However, convection is still significant in insulation systems on Mars and this reduces the effectiveness of MLI<ref name=":0" /> to about the same as other systems. MeMLi, Multiple Environment MLI is under development to increase the effectiveness of this type of insulation on Mars<ref>https://data.nasa.gov/dataset/Multi-Environment-MLI-Novel-Multi-functional-Insul/5hw6-3x2x/data</ref>. 
  
−
[[w:Foam_glass|Foam glass]] is another form or insulation than can be produced locally and should have superior insulation properties,as well as good structural properties.  Foam insulation on Mars has very low convection and radiation rates.  The heat transfer comes essentially from conduction in the cell walls.
+
[[w:Foam_glass|Foam glass]] is another form or insulation than can be produced locally and should have superior insulation properties, as well as good structural properties.  Foam insulation on Mars has very low convection and radiation rates.  The heat transfer comes essentially from conduction in the cell walls.
  
 
Fiberglass and mineral wool would not function as insulators in the same way on Mars as they do on Earth.  Fiberglass is not itself an insulator.  The insulation comes from the thermal resistance of the air in the fiberglass mat.  The resistance of the air in increased because it cannot flow freely over the surfaces, reducing convective heat transfer significantly.  Fiberglass is also installed with a reflective vapor barrier, that adds to its insulation value.   
 
Fiberglass and mineral wool would not function as insulators in the same way on Mars as they do on Earth.  Fiberglass is not itself an insulator.  The insulation comes from the thermal resistance of the air in the fiberglass mat.  The resistance of the air in increased because it cannot flow freely over the surfaces, reducing convective heat transfer significantly.  Fiberglass is also installed with a reflective vapor barrier, that adds to its insulation value.   
  
 
[[Image:metal_foil_box.jpg|right|frame|A block of ice wrapped in aluminium foil to prevent melting.]]
 
[[Image:metal_foil_box.jpg|right|frame|A block of ice wrapped in aluminium foil to prevent melting.]]
 +
 +
[[Smart Windows]] would be useful.
  
 
==Insulation table==
 
==Insulation table==
−
The following table shows some insulation values for materials on Mars<ref name=":0">https://trs.jpl.nasa.gov/bitstream/handle/2014/22216/97-0683.pdf?sequence=1</ref>.  The exact value will need to be tested on Mars, and will vary significantly if the material is used inside a habitat at Earth atmospheric pressure or outside the habitat at martian atmospheric pressure.
+
The following table shows some insulation values for materials on Mars<ref name=":0">https://trs.jpl.nasa.gov/bitstream/handle/2014/22216/97-0683.pdf?sequence=1</ref>.  The exact value will need to be tested on Mars, and will vary significantly if the material is used inside a habitat at Earth atmospheric pressure or outside the habitat at Martian atmospheric pressure.
  
−
Most insulation is used in assemblies.  Structural elements may have high conductivity and decrease thermal resistance.
+
Most insulation is used in assemblies.  Structural elements may have high conductivity and decrease thermal resistance.  Combination of materials, films and radiation reflective surfaces can modify insulation values significantly.
 
{| class="wikitable"
 
{| class="wikitable"
 
|+Table of insulation materials
 
|+Table of insulation materials
 
!Material
 
!Material
−
!Thermal conductivity (k) (W/m/C)
+
!Thermal conductivity (k) (W/m*C)
 
!Density
 
!Density
 
kg/m3
 
kg/m3
 
![[Embodied energy]] (MJ/kg)
 
![[Embodied energy]] (MJ/kg)
 +
!Heat loss (Q)(W/m2)
 
!Notes
 
!Notes
 
|-
 
|-
−
|Multi layer insulation
+
|Multi layer insulation<ref>https://aip.scitation.org/doi/pdf/10.1063/1.2908509</ref><ref>https://aip.scitation.org/doi/pdf/10.1063/1.4707081</ref><ref>https://www.researchgate.net/publication/327289988_Thermal_performance_of_multilayer_insulation_A_review</ref>
 +
|10e-5 in space but lower on Mars
 +
|
 
|
 
|
 +
|0,2-1 space
 +
10-50 Mars
 +
|This insulation's effectiveness varies with the number of layers. No mechanical strength.  Sensitive to convection. 20 to 40 layers. Usually a few mm thick. 1.5 kg/m2
 +
|-
 +
|MEMLi<ref>MEMLI.  https://www.sbir.gov/sbirsearch/detail/1561563</ref>
 +
|10e-5
 
|
 
|
 
|
 
|
−
|This insulation's effectiveness varies with the number of layers. No mechanical strength. Sensitive to convection
+
|0,2
 +
|Multi Environment Multi Layer Insulation.  10 layers. 1.5 kg/m2.
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Foam glass
 
|Foam glass
 
|0,038
 
|0,038
 
|160
 
|160
−
|30?
+
|26<ref name=":1">http://www.greenspec.co.uk/building-design/insulation-mineral/</ref>
 +
|76
 
|Might be produced in-situ. Relatively high mechanical strength
 
|Might be produced in-situ. Relatively high mechanical strength
 
|-
 
|-
Line 43: Line 56:
 
|7-12<ref>http://www.fao.org/3/y5013e/y5013e08.htm</ref>
 
|7-12<ref>http://www.fao.org/3/y5013e/y5013e08.htm</ref>
 
|28
 
|28
 +
|20-40
 
|No mechanical strength
 
|No mechanical strength
 
|-
 
|-
−
|Foam
+
|Foams
 
|0,02 to 0,04
 
|0,02 to 0,04
 
|20-30
 
|20-30
−
|<nowiki>+100 MJ/kg</nowiki>
+
| +100
 +
|40-80
 
|Might have problems from outgassing. Some mechanical strength
 
|Might have problems from outgassing. Some mechanical strength
 
|-
 
|-
Line 55: Line 70:
 
|
 
|
 
|17
 
|17
 +
|20-40
 
|No mechanical strength
 
|No mechanical strength
 
|-
 
|-
−
|Aerogel
+
|[[Aerogel]]
 
|0,005 to 0,01
 
|0,005 to 0,01
 
|16
 
|16
−
|?
+
|53<ref name=":1" />
 +
|10-20
 +
|
 +
|-
 +
|[[w:Vacuum_insulated_panel|Vacuum insulated panel]]
 +
|0.007
 +
|256
 
|
 
|
 +
|14
 +
|0,003 for the insulation, reduced to 0,007 for installation thermal bridges, loss is for 50mm panels<ref>http://www.thermalvisions.com/Theshhold_page.html</ref>
 
|-
 
|-
−
|Regolith
+
|Air
−
|0,02 to 0,1
+
|0,02
−
|1600-2200
+
|1,2
−
|0,1
+
|
−
|Variable, usually on the higher side when used compacted
+
|40
 +
|About the same for Mars atmosphere as for Earth
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Water
 
|Water
Line 73: Line 98:
 
|1000
 
|1000
 
|0,5
 
|0,5
 +
|1200
 
|Water is not a good insulator
 
|Water is not a good insulator
 +
|-
 +
|Regolith
 +
|0,15-2
 +
|1800-2000
 +
|0.08
 +
|300-4000
 +
|Depends on compaction and composition. Embodied energy is the energy of aggregate (gravel).
 +
|-
 +
|Rock
 +
|2-4
 +
|1800-2000
 +
|
 +
|4000-8000
 +
|
 +
|-
 +
|Aluminium alloys
 +
|50-100
 +
|2700
 +
|155-220
 +
|200 000
 +
|This is why it is important to minimize themal bridging
 
|}
 
|}
 +
 +
The heat loss was calculated for -75C  exterior to 25C interior, and a thickness of 50mm.
  
 
Basic calculation:
 
Basic calculation:
  
−
Q=k*A*t*(ti-to) where
+
Q=k/t*A*(ti-to) or Q=UAdt      where:
 +
*k/t=U Heat transfer coefficient
 +
*Q=Heat loss  (Watts) (J/s)
 +
*k= Thermal conductivity (W/m°C)
 +
*A=Wall area  (m2)
 +
*t=material thickness (m)
 +
*ti-to= dt= temperature difference between interior and exterior (°K)
  
−
Q=Heat loss  (Watts) (J/s)
+
== Multi layer insulation ==
 +
For multilayer insulation the following equation can be used:
  
−
A=Wall area  (m2)
+
'''U=4*B*T<sup>3</sup>/N*(2e-1)+1'''
  
−
t=material thickness (m)
+
*B is the Stephen Boltzman constant = 5,67e-8 W/m<sup>2</sup>K<sup>4</sup>
 +
*T is the average temperature between the two surfaces, Exterior and interior = Te+Ti/2
 +
*e=Emissivity of the layers
 +
*N=number of layers
  
−
ti-to= temperature difference between interior and exterior (°K)
+
The actual conductivity will be higher, due to the need for spacers in the MLI that add some conduction to the assembly.
  
 
==Tank insulation==
 
==Tank insulation==
 
Insulation of fuel tanks on Mars may be a requirement to prevent accumulation of frozen CO<sub>2</sub> on tanks.  CO<sub>2</sub> freezes a little bellow -67C and could accumulate significant mass on a fuel tank.  Tank insulation needs to have a vapor barrier, or be composed of closed cells to avoid the risk of condensation in the insulation and the accumulation of water or CO<sub>2</sub> ice in the material.
 
Insulation of fuel tanks on Mars may be a requirement to prevent accumulation of frozen CO<sub>2</sub> on tanks.  CO<sub>2</sub> freezes a little bellow -67C and could accumulate significant mass on a fuel tank.  Tank insulation needs to have a vapor barrier, or be composed of closed cells to avoid the risk of condensation in the insulation and the accumulation of water or CO<sub>2</sub> ice in the material.
 +
 +
==Coatings==
 +
Coatings can modify the emissivity of surfaces or their solar absorbance significantly<ref>PETTIT, R. B. et SOWELL, R. R. Solar absorptance and emittance properties of several solar coatings. ''Journal of vacuum Science and technology'', 1976, vol. 13, no 2, p. 596-602.</ref><ref>HENNINGER, John H. ''Solar Absorptance and Thermal Emittance of Some Common Spacecraft Thermal-Control Coatings''. NATIONAL AERONAUTICS AND SPACE ADMINISTRATION WASHINGTON DC, 1984.</ref>.  Thermal radiation from a structure' surface and convection from the Martian atmosphere add loses to an insulated structure.  During the day, solar heat gain can be affected by coatings as well.
  
 
==Production==
 
==Production==
 
Insulation can be produced [[In-situ resource utilization|in-situ]].  The very low atmospheric pressure of Mars already provides a good insulation, reducing heat transfer from convection.
 
Insulation can be produced [[In-situ resource utilization|in-situ]].  The very low atmospheric pressure of Mars already provides a good insulation, reducing heat transfer from convection.
  
−
[[w:Foam_glass|Foam glass]] would be an interesting type of insulation to produce on Mars.  The resources, mainly silica oxide, are available in large quantities.  An adequate foaming agent would need to be identified and mined and the production process refined to create a viable product.   
+
[[w:Foam_glass|Foam glass]] would be an interesting type of insulation to produce on Mars.  The resources, mainly silica oxide, are available in large quantities.  An adequate foaming agent would need to be identified and mined and the production process refined to create a viable product.  Foam glass combined with a suitable reflective covering might achieve results similar to Vacuum Insulated Panels.   
  
 
Fiber glass and mineral wool can both be produced in-situ.   
 
Fiber glass and mineral wool can both be produced in-situ.   
  
−
==Open issue==
+
Plastic foams can be produced in-situ, however the energy requirements are much higher than for other types of insulation. 
−
 
 
−
*What is the heat transfer coefficient of regolith, aerogel and other materials?
 
−
*What can be produced in-situ with low energy consumption?
 
  
 
==References==
 
==References==
 
[[Category:Construction, Assembly, Maintenance]]
 
[[Category:Construction, Assembly, Maintenance]]
 +
[[Category:Spacecraft design]]
 
<references />
 
<references />

Latest revision as of 22:10, 16 September 2024

Sheets of foamed polystyrene for insulation of houses.

Thermal Insulation is needed to keep a colony warm and reduces the consumption of energy for heating. Aerogel or plastic foam may be utilized for insulation. Regolith may be heaped over buildings to keep in heat. Mineral wools such as Fiberglass, spun from local resources, may provide alternative insulation.

The glass body of a vacuum flask.

Insulation on Mars

The thin Martian atmosphere has a reduced capability for a convective flow of heat. More important is the heat radiation, which can be effectively reduced by choosing the material of the building's surface. A smooth bright metallic surface emits much less heat radiation than a rough black one. A simple aluminium coated foil wrapped around the settlement modules provides excellent insulation. Multi-layer insulation (MLI) of the same type of foil can reduce heat loss to very low numbers and is commonly used for satellites. However, convection is still significant in insulation systems on Mars and this reduces the effectiveness of MLI[1] to about the same as other systems. MeMLi, Multiple Environment MLI is under development to increase the effectiveness of this type of insulation on Mars[2].

Foam glass is another form or insulation than can be produced locally and should have superior insulation properties, as well as good structural properties. Foam insulation on Mars has very low convection and radiation rates. The heat transfer comes essentially from conduction in the cell walls.

Fiberglass and mineral wool would not function as insulators in the same way on Mars as they do on Earth. Fiberglass is not itself an insulator. The insulation comes from the thermal resistance of the air in the fiberglass mat. The resistance of the air in increased because it cannot flow freely over the surfaces, reducing convective heat transfer significantly. Fiberglass is also installed with a reflective vapor barrier, that adds to its insulation value.

A block of ice wrapped in aluminium foil to prevent melting.

Smart Windows would be useful.

Insulation table

The following table shows some insulation values for materials on Mars[1]. The exact value will need to be tested on Mars, and will vary significantly if the material is used inside a habitat at Earth atmospheric pressure or outside the habitat at Martian atmospheric pressure.

Most insulation is used in assemblies. Structural elements may have high conductivity and decrease thermal resistance. Combination of materials, films and radiation reflective surfaces can modify insulation values significantly.

Table of insulation materials
Material Thermal conductivity (k) (W/m*C) Density

kg/m3

Embodied energy (MJ/kg) Heat loss (Q)(W/m2) Notes
Multi layer insulation[3][4][5] 10e-5 in space but lower on Mars 0,2-1 space

10-50 Mars

This insulation's effectiveness varies with the number of layers. No mechanical strength. Sensitive to convection. 20 to 40 layers. Usually a few mm thick. 1.5 kg/m2
MEMLi[6] 10e-5 0,2 Multi Environment Multi Layer Insulation. 10 layers. 1.5 kg/m2.
Foam glass 0,038 160 26[7] 76 Might be produced in-situ. Relatively high mechanical strength
Fiber glass 0,01 to 0,02 7-12[8] 28 20-40 No mechanical strength
Foams 0,02 to 0,04 20-30 +100 40-80 Might have problems from outgassing. Some mechanical strength
Mineral wool 0,01 to 0,02 17 20-40 No mechanical strength
Aerogel 0,005 to 0,01 16 53[7] 10-20
Vacuum insulated panel 0.007 256 14 0,003 for the insulation, reduced to 0,007 for installation thermal bridges, loss is for 50mm panels[9]
Air 0,02 1,2 40 About the same for Mars atmosphere as for Earth
Water 0,6 1000 0,5 1200 Water is not a good insulator
Regolith 0,15-2 1800-2000 0.08 300-4000 Depends on compaction and composition. Embodied energy is the energy of aggregate (gravel).
Rock 2-4 1800-2000 4000-8000
Aluminium alloys 50-100 2700 155-220 200 000 This is why it is important to minimize themal bridging

The heat loss was calculated for -75C exterior to 25C interior, and a thickness of 50mm.

Basic calculation:

Q=k/t*A*(ti-to) or Q=UAdt where:

  • k/t=U Heat transfer coefficient
  • Q=Heat loss (Watts) (J/s)
  • k= Thermal conductivity (W/m°C)
  • A=Wall area (m2)
  • t=material thickness (m)
  • ti-to= dt= temperature difference between interior and exterior (°K)

Multi layer insulation

For multilayer insulation the following equation can be used:

U=4*B*T3/N*(2e-1)+1

  • B is the Stephen Boltzman constant = 5,67e-8 W/m2K4
  • T is the average temperature between the two surfaces, Exterior and interior = Te+Ti/2
  • e=Emissivity of the layers
  • N=number of layers

The actual conductivity will be higher, due to the need for spacers in the MLI that add some conduction to the assembly.

Tank insulation

Insulation of fuel tanks on Mars may be a requirement to prevent accumulation of frozen CO2 on tanks. CO2 freezes a little bellow -67C and could accumulate significant mass on a fuel tank. Tank insulation needs to have a vapor barrier, or be composed of closed cells to avoid the risk of condensation in the insulation and the accumulation of water or CO2 ice in the material.

Coatings

Coatings can modify the emissivity of surfaces or their solar absorbance significantly[10][11]. Thermal radiation from a structure' surface and convection from the Martian atmosphere add loses to an insulated structure. During the day, solar heat gain can be affected by coatings as well.

Production

Insulation can be produced in-situ. The very low atmospheric pressure of Mars already provides a good insulation, reducing heat transfer from convection.

Foam glass would be an interesting type of insulation to produce on Mars. The resources, mainly silica oxide, are available in large quantities. An adequate foaming agent would need to be identified and mined and the production process refined to create a viable product. Foam glass combined with a suitable reflective covering might achieve results similar to Vacuum Insulated Panels.

Fiber glass and mineral wool can both be produced in-situ.

Plastic foams can be produced in-situ, however the energy requirements are much higher than for other types of insulation.

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 https://trs.jpl.nasa.gov/bitstream/handle/2014/22216/97-0683.pdf?sequence=1
  2. ↑ https://data.nasa.gov/dataset/Multi-Environment-MLI-Novel-Multi-functional-Insul/5hw6-3x2x/data
  3. ↑ https://aip.scitation.org/doi/pdf/10.1063/1.2908509
  4. ↑ https://aip.scitation.org/doi/pdf/10.1063/1.4707081
  5. ↑ https://www.researchgate.net/publication/327289988_Thermal_performance_of_multilayer_insulation_A_review
  6. ↑ MEMLI. https://www.sbir.gov/sbirsearch/detail/1561563
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 http://www.greenspec.co.uk/building-design/insulation-mineral/
  8. ↑ http://www.fao.org/3/y5013e/y5013e08.htm
  9. ↑ http://www.thermalvisions.com/Theshhold_page.html
  10. ↑ PETTIT, R. B. et SOWELL, R. R. Solar absorptance and emittance properties of several solar coatings. Journal of vacuum Science and technology, 1976, vol. 13, no 2, p. 596-602.
  11. ↑ HENNINGER, John H. Solar Absorptance and Thermal Emittance of Some Common Spacecraft Thermal-Control Coatings. NATIONAL AERONAUTICS AND SPACE ADMINISTRATION WASHINGTON DC, 1984.
Retrieved from "https://marspedia.org/index.php?title=Insulation&oldid=141625"